SPREAD LOVE

Mouthwatering Crispy Dill Pickle Grilled Cheese Sandwich

There’s something comfortingly familiar about gooey cheese between toasty bread — but add a layer of tangy, crunchy dill pickles and you’ve got a playful twist that sparks nostalgia for diner lunches and summer picnics. This sandwich balances melty, savory cheese with bright vinegar bite and a satisfyingly crispy exterior, making every bite both indulgent and refreshingly bold. For a crunchy, snackable companion idea, check out these crispy pickle cheese bites that echo the spirit of this sandwich.

Why make this recipe

It’s a fast, satisfying upgrade to ordinary grilled cheese: minimal fuss, maximum flavor.
The dill pickles cut through rich, melted cheese for a perfectly balanced bite.
This sandwich is ideal when you want something classic with a clever, craveable twist that’s quick enough for weeknights but special enough for guests.

Ingredients

8 slices sturdy bread (e.g., sourdough, challah, brioche)
12 oz melting cheese blend, grated (e.g., 6 oz sharp cheddar, 6 oz Monterey Jack or Gruyère)
1/2 to 3/4 cup dill pickle slices or chips, well-drained and patted dry
4–6 tbsp unsalted butter, softened
2 tbsp mayonnaise (optional, for exterior)
1/2 tsp garlic powder (optional)
Freshly ground black pepper, to taste (optional)

Step-by-Step Guide to Making Mouthwatering Crispy Dill Pickle Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Pat the dill pickle slices very dry with paper towels; set aside. This step is crucial to prevent soggy bread. Excess pickle moisture is the number-one enemy of crispness, so take the time to press and pat as dry as you can.
Grate your sharp cheddar and chosen creamy cheese, then mix them together in a bowl. Using a blend gives you sharp savory notes from cheddar and smooth melt from Monterey Jack or Gruyère; grate freshly for best melting and texture.
In a small bowl, combine softened unsalted butter with optional garlic powder and a few grinds of black pepper. Have mayonnaise ready in a separate dish if you choose to use it for the exterior. A thin layer of mayo browns beautifully and helps create an ultra-crisp crust if you prefer it to butter-only.
Lay out the eight slices of bread. Generously spread one side of each slice with the flavored butter (or a thin, even layer of mayonnaise) for the exterior. Be even but liberal — a well-buttered surface makes for an irresistible golden crust.
Take four of the bread slices (with the buttered/mayo-ed side down, facing your work surface) and sprinkle a generous, even layer of half of your mixed grated cheese over each, extending almost to the edges. Don’t skimp — the cheese is the glue that holds everything together.
Arrange the thoroughly dried dill pickle slices in a single, even layer on top of the cheese on these four bread slices. Keep the pickles in one layer so every bite has balance: too many overlapping pickles can make leaking liquids concentrate and weigh the sandwich down.
Top the pickles with the remaining generous layer of mixed grated cheese, which will act as a delicious glue. This top layer of cheese helps seal the pickles and ensures gooey pull when the sandwich opens.
Finally, place the remaining four buttered/mayo-ed bread slices on top of the cheese and pickle stack, ensuring the buttered/mayo-ed side is facing up. Gently press down on each sandwich to consolidate the layers. If you like a tighter sandwich, press slightly with a palm or a spatula.
Preheat a large, heavy-bottomed skillet or griddle over medium-low heat for 3–5 minutes until evenly hot. Patience here is key: medium-low ensures the bread browns without the cheese burning or the exterior over-crisping before the interior melts.
Carefully place one or two of your assembled sandwiches into the preheated pan, ensuring not to overcrowd. Give each sandwich space so heat circulates evenly and you can flip safely.
Cook for about 4–6 minutes on the first side. Look for a deep golden-brown color and for the cheese on the bottom layer to start visibly melting. (Optional: place a heavy, heat-proof plate or another skillet on top to gently press the sandwiches for a more compact and consistently crispy crust). Using a press helps create even contact with the pan and increases caramelization.
Carefully flip each sandwich using a wide spatula. If the pan seems dry, add a small pat of butter. Cook for another 4–6 minutes, or until the second side is also deeply golden-brown and crispy, and all the cheese inside is completely melted and gooey. (Optional: About halfway through cooking the second side, you can place a lid over the skillet for 1–2 minutes to help the cheese melt faster, then remove to re-crisp the bread). If you used mayo outside, you’ll notice a particularly even brown that’s slightly glossy.
Repeat the cooking process with any remaining sandwiches, adjusting the heat as necessary between batches. If things brown too quickly, lower the heat a notch — finished sandwiches are worth the extra time.
Transfer the cooked sandwiches from the skillet to a cutting board. Let them rest for about 1–2 minutes; this allows the molten cheese to set slightly, preventing excessive oozing when cut. A short rest yields neater slices without losing the melty factor.
With a sharp, serrated knife, cut each sandwich in half, either diagonally (for visual appeal) or straight across. Diagonal halves tend to show more of the melty interior and are classic diner-style.
For an all-around crispy experience, you can carefully use tongs to hold the sandwich on its edges in the hot pan for about 30 seconds per edge after the main cooking. This quick edge-toasting seals corners and gives a finished professional touch.
Serve your incredible Crispy Dill Pickle Grilled Cheese Sandwich immediately while still warm, crispy, and wonderfully melty. It pairs perfectly with tomato soup or a fresh green salad. Enjoy the irresistible contrast of textures and flavors: crunchy, sharp, tangy, and creamy.

Best Way to Store Mouthwatering Crispy Dill Pickle Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Refrigerate in an airtight container for up to 3 days at 40°F (4°C). To maintain some crispness, separate layers with parchment and avoid pressing the sandwiches flat.
For longer storage, freeze wrapped sandwiches in foil and placed inside a freezer-safe bag for up to 1 month at 0°F (-18°C). Reheat from frozen in a low oven (350°F / 175°C) for 12–20 minutes, then pan-sear briefly to re-crisp.
When reheating from refrigerated, use a skillet over low heat, flipping often and adding a tiny pat of butter to revive the crust; lid for a minute if cheese needs help melting.

Serving Suggestions for Mouthwatering Crispy Dill Pickle Grilled Cheese Sandwich

A classic pairing is warm tomato soup — the acidity of the tomatoes complements the pickles and melts.
Serve alongside a crisp green salad dressed lightly with lemon vinaigrette to cut through richness.
For a casual meal, offer a trio of dipping options: ketchup, a smoky chipotle mayo, and a creamy ranch — each brings different flavor dimensions to the sandwich.

Tips to make Mouthwatering Crispy Dill Pickle Grilled Cheese Sandwich (Q&A style)
Q: How do I keep the sandwich from getting soggy?
A: The most important step is patting the pickles very dry. Use paper towels and press firmly. Also, avoid overstacking pickles; a single layer is enough.

Q: Should I use butter or mayonnaise for the outside?
A: Butter gives rich browning and flavor, while mayonnaise creates an even, golden crust that browns reliably. Try both and use whichever finish you prefer.

Q: How can I ensure the cheese melts evenly?
A: Grate your cheeses finely and use a moderate cooking temperature (medium-low). Cover the pan briefly if needed to help the interior heat through.

Variation (if any)

Quick bacon add-in (bullet): Crisp 4 slices of bacon, roughly chop, and sprinkle over the cheese before adding pickles. The smoky bacon plays delightfully with the tangy pickles and melty cheese.
Vegetarian upgrade (paragraph): If you’d like a fresher, slightly lighter take, swap half the cheddar for a tangy young manchego and add thinly sliced apple or pear with the pickles. The fruit adds a sweet-tart counterpoint that complements the dill and cheese without overwhelming the classic profile.

FAQs

Q: Can I use jarred sandwich slices or bread other than sourdough?
A: Yes — use any sturdy bread with a tight crumb such as challah or brioche. Avoid extremely soft sandwich bread if you want a crisp exterior.

Q: What’s the best cheese combo?
A: A blend of sharp cheddar and a good-melting cheese (Monterey Jack or Gruyère) is ideal. Cheddar gives flavor; the milder cheese ensures stringy melt.

Q: Can I make this gluten-free?
A: Absolutely. Use a sturdy gluten-free bread and follow the same steps. Be mindful that some gluten-free breads brown faster; adjust heat accordingly.

Q: How do I make this for a crowd?
A: Assemble sandwiches and grill them in batches, keeping finished ones loosely tented with foil in a low oven (200°F / 95°C) to hold while you finish the rest.

Q: Is it okay to use dill relish instead of slices?
A: Relish is much wetter and will make the sandwich soggy unless you reduce moisture significantly. If using relish, blot it thoroughly and use a smaller amount.

Final notes and serving etiquette

Keep napkins handy — melty grilled cheese is gloriously messy in the best way.
For presentation, cut sandwiches diagonally and stack halves slightly askew on a warm plate, garnish with a few extra pickle chips or a small herb sprig.
Pair with a cold glass of iced tea or a crisp lager for a classic diner vibe.

Conclusion

For more creative pickle-and-cheese mashups you can try another imaginative take in this Stonefire recipe for a naan-based option featuring dill pickles and cheddar: Stonefire’s naan grilled cheese with dill pickles. If you want another tried-and-true inspiration built around classic pickles and melted cheese, the Mt. Olive kitchen shares a tasty approach here: Mt Olive’s pickle grilled cheese recipe.